Updated: TRC sees a soldier

16 02 2011

The Bangkok Post says that, at long last, an “army officer who commanded soldiers during the “krachab puenti” (seizing back the area) operation against red-shirt protesters on April 10, 2010…” has finally shown up to speak with the  Truth for Reconciliation Committee’s fact-finding sub-committee. Reader’s may recall that just a week or so ago, no soldier had been permitted to talk with the administration’s own committee, chaired by Somchai Homlaor.

Colonel Thammanoon Withee, head of the 1st Army Command’s Operations Unit, was the man assigned the duty of speaking to the committee. PPT guesses that this sudden change of heart from the military is meant to be about deflecting the accusations made in the recent Amsterdam & Peroff report to the International Criminal Court.

GofHyper Photo

While the Colonel says “he regrets the loss of lives,” that “his men were overwhelmed by numbers and attacked by unknown assailants using guns and explosives,” and that the red shirts “would like to overthrow the present regime with either armed fighting or mass uprisings,” the real story he tells is of an operation that went wrong, of army unpreparedness for civil action, and of panic and failure.

He says “his troops could not accomplish the mission they were assigned by their superiors on that day…”. He claims that there were only a “few thousand troops [that] … faced tens of thousands of protesters, whose numbers grew quickly into the evening and night…”. He claims his deployment was delayed and that his men could only get into position at 5 p.m. Facing the demonstrators, his men didn’t have any supplies and were “sealed off and out numbered by protesters,” who seem not to have been aggressive given that the protesters provided the soldiers with food and water. Thammanoon said “his boss ordered to halt the operation by 18.15 but he just could not withdraw from the areas.”

He says that those doing the shooting “were not us.” Readers interested in video and pictures of the event might begin with our Battle for Bangkok page or here. There’s plenty of video of soldiers shooting, both in daytime and into the evening.

The colonel claims that the blasts that killed soldiers were, contra the Amsterdam & Peroff account, “were not from hand grenades or M-79, otherwise more military and civilians would have been killed due to the packed space. He believed they were improvised explosive devices since a dozen nails were found from the blasts.” As far as PPT is aware, and readers might correct us, we have not heard of confirmed injuries caused by an IED packed with nails.

Thammanoon says he and troops were trapped and unable to retreat, and that it was opposition politicians and red shirts who helped them get back to their fellow troops. Some soldiers were attacked, he says, because “protesters were informed that troops killed their colleagues. But there were also those Red-Shirted protesters who helped stop the beating and helped us to get out of the areas.” The videos mentioned above also show soldiers firing on red shirt medics trying to assist injured soldiers.

In an interesting footnote to this story, “Priya Nawamala, a public relations officer at the state-run TV channel 11, said his agency was part of the blame for the loss of the Thai people.” Priya says this because the “government has been using the NBT to portray the protesting side as unpatriotic and anti-monarchic. They should have been offering some more neutral voices instead of igniting the hatred against one another…”.

Update: Bangkok Pundit has a post where more attention is given to the above footnote on NBT as a pawn of the regime.



One response

16 02 2011
Tweets that mention TRC sees a soldier | Political Prisoners in Thailand -- Topsy.com

[…] This post was mentioned on Twitter by NEWSpace, อิสระภาพ แห่งข่าวสาร. อิสระภาพ แห่งข่าวสาร said: TRC sees a soldier: The Bangkok Post says that, at long last, an “army officer who commanded soldiers during the… http://bit.ly/gPDqkh […]